Friday, March 1, 2024

Warners'Stellian Appliance Sucks Donkey Dick

 2-28-2024


Warners'Stellian Appliance Sucks Donkey Dick: Just a Personal Opinion 


Believe it, or not, below is the very brief, condensed conclusion to my earlier post regarding my Warners'Stellian experience, dated 10-23-2023


The Good News: After I tried 5 times, by phone, to get the rebate company, the prepaid credit card issuing company, and Warners'Stellian Appliance to cease trying to rip me off, and to send my prepaid credit card for $1000.00;  I filed a complaint with the Better Business Bureau of California. ( Then I discovered that complaints are only seen by the company, so easily ignored).  So, I filed a very negative Review with the Minnesota BBB, (which is seen by the public).  Warners'Stellian simply ignored the BBB.  Turns out that the BBB is a paper tiger, and a waste of consumer time.

So I contacted the Minnesota Attorney General's Office, jumped through a million hoops, as I had already done, twice, with the BBB, and a rep was assigned to my case.  The rep contacted WS, and WS replied a first and last time, that they wanted more info.  (Blah Blah Blah).  So the Atty Gen Office tried for about three months to help, and finally notified me that WS was ignoring them.  Turns out the Attny Gen has impressive headers on their mailings, but no power of enforcement, so is simply ignored.  They do keep a record of your complaint, which is mighty nice of them. If hundreds of WS clients file complaints, they may possibly look into it.  Another Paper Tiger with an impressive Letter Head.

So finally, I jumped through another million, or more hoops, ( The Courts, Conciliation Court included, have gone online for all documents, suits, exhibits, hearings…everything.  This of course separates the common little old man, and anyone else, who is not a computer expert from almost any hope of even getting a hearing. If you do get to argue your case, you argue it through Zoom.  You are detached from standing in a courtroom, before a judge,( no you don't get a Judge, you get someone else, who is a Referee, who somehow got appointed to pretend he/she is a judge.  And you do have to say "Your Honor", and pretend the person is a judge. No confronting the defendant in person.) Convenience of the Court, and any attorney is paramount.  Justice is not.  

I did eventually file a suit in Conciliation Court.  The summons to appear did get WS attention. 

WS General Counsel ( WS attorney) called me, and we had a nice discussion.  She must have contacted the rebate co., who contacted me.  

The email the rebate co. sent, said "Congratulations your Virtual Prepaid Card is Just a click Away!  Luckily I had already taken my blood pressure medication.  

8 minutes later, I got another email saying Case Resolved! Then, I got a voice message. ( I would tell you that all of the people I spoke with, in all of my conversations with the other companies, were Latino, and spoke halting English as a second language, and were next to impossible to understand, but I would be designated Racist and Cancelled, so I am not going to mention that.) 

Eventually they mailed the $1000.00 card to me.  I spent it in 8 days, before they found some way to cut it off.  My cupboards are full of coffee filters. So I got my promised rebate, and spent the money fast.  Yay!!!  That's the good news.


The bad news is that they still owed me the $77.00 court fee.  The WS General Counsel refused to pay it.  Her position was that I was suing the wrong company.  Are you freaking kidding me?   I was pissed(can you tell?), so I refused to ask the court to dismiss the case.

Instead, I spent a zillion hours ( Jeez, I remember that Superman Series, on TV…a hundred years ago….."Truth, Justice, and the American way".  Yes. Yes. I know that those concepts are too, too, funny.  I do try to entertain my readers.)   I learned how to pretend that I was an attorney,  learned how to submit 15 exhibits as evidence.  I got a ton of help, on two different days, from two very knowledgeable, extremely helpful, librarians at the county law library, at the courthouse.  I got my Zoom hearing.  I used the law library computer, at the courthouse. Yes. The librarian set it up for me, and supplied headphones, when I could not hear.   Having seen my image on Zoom, with headphones,  I probably should have just struggled to hear the participants.

I presented part of my argument, via Zoom.   The WS general counsel argued that WS was an innocent victim, that I should have sued the rebate co.

I attempted to explain to the judge that WS offered the rebates on their website, and that the salesman did the same, and that my contract was with WS not the rebate company.  I read explicit evidence…blah, blah, blah.  

The referee has many cases to get through, every day, before he can put his feet up and drink his coffee. 

So he cut me off, and started telling me what a great job I had done.  So, of course, I instantly knew that I would not be hearing that BS, unless I was screwed.  He agreed with the General Council, that I should have sued the rebate co., and dismissed the case. Poof, coffee time.

How does one get to be a referee, I wonder?  Does one actually have to attend a law school?  Does one actually have to pass the Universal Bar Exam? Or does a referee get his credentials from a box of Cracker Jacks?  Are all referee's dim bulbs, who volunteer for that job because they cannot find work as attorney's?

 

On my way home, it was a beautiful, sunny day, and 65 degrees.  I realized two things.  

First, I broke the KISS rule, the "keep it simple, stupid" rule.  (I sometimes have been known to be rather long winded.  Are you still reading?)  If I had done that, maybe I could have dumbed it down enough, so the court could understand.


Second, in spite of reading a quote from the sheet of paper, the credit card was attached to, which said, and I do quote,  "This reward is offered by your local business from whom you recently made a purchase";  I should have pointed out to this highly educated referee,  the five basic necessities for a valid contract.  Number three being, "An exchange of something of value between the parties."  In this case, the money from me, and the 6 appliances, and three rebates from WS.  I learned those five requirements when I took a Contract Law Class, from a very talented attorney, many years ago, in college.  I got an A.  I can prove it.  I have my college transcript stashed somewhere.   I gave nothing of value to the rebate co., so I had no contract with them.  Maybe if I would have been able to think faster, and added that no contract, to my first Zoom experience, before it was time for the referee's coffee break, I would have won.  No. I have always been a slow thinker.

I have considered filing an appeal, but I don't know if one can appeal a decision of a referee, who does not know the law, in Conciliation Court. (No you can not Appeal, I asked.  So you got lucky and will not hear any more sour grapes about Conciliation Court)


In conclusion,  I got $923.00 of the money they owed me.  I spent the other $77.00, finally getting the attention of WS through a summons.  If you are getting screwed, do not waste time going to the BBB, nor the Minnesota Attorney Generals Office.  And understand that if you win, and get a judgement, in your favor, in court, that the court does not make them pay.  

So, as we all know, this country is in a state of decline.  Justice? You're kidding right?  Speed, Convenience…Zoom!

One last repeated opinion, which is not fact, and certainly not advice on where to shop,(Is my butt covered?) but simply my opinion, based on my one, 6 month nightmare experience of being a customer of WS:

Warners'Stellian Appliance Sucks Donkey Dick! 


So it goes……

 

Friday, October 13, 2023

 


Warners Stellian Appliance Nightmare


10-13-2023


The Bottom Line is This:  Don't Do It!  Don't even think about buying your new appliances from this Retailer!  Run away, drive away, escape while you can.  Do not get sucked into the Warners Stellian vortex, of supposed best prices and unending rebates.  Warners Stellian is a nightmare!  They will threaten you with ultimatums, arrive with damaged appliances, poke holes in your walls, two of the three times, when six people, plus a plumber, 7 total, arrive to install your appliances, on three different days, and come unprepared to use longer bolts to install your Microwave.  Seven days later when your appliances are all finally installed, and you apply for your promised rebates, the company, Warners Stellian employs to handle rebates,  Nationwide Marketing Group,( who actually employs Blackhawk Network Holdings Inc. to fulfill card services) will not provide the rebate as ordered, will stonewall you when you try to get what you ordered, and the Woodbury Minnesota Warners Stellian Sales Manager, Jason Weatherby, will not return your phone call, nor respond to your voice message.  Your salesman at Woodbury Minnesota, Ben Drucker,  will tell you that it is not his, nor Warner Stellian's problem. 

You have been warned.


If you want to know the complete details of this tragedy , and have a lot of time, below is my tale of woe to date:  It ain't over.


My refrigerator got old and tired, and quit working on Friday September 1, 2023.  All six of the appliances in my townhome were 18 years old.   I got advice from two family members, then looked online, at refrigerators.  Warners Stellian was having their Labor Day Sale, plus offering multiple rebates.  Oh my!   I noted online that the Woodbury Minnesota store opened at 8:30 AM  the next day.  On September 2, 2023, I beat a path to Woodbury the next morning, parked my vehicle, and arrived at the door at 8:30 AM.  Big mistake.  I was told the store did not open until 9:00 AM.  The start time on the web page said 8:30AM. ( I noted later that there are two different web pages produced by the company.  One says 8:30 AM, the other says 9:00 AM.)  I waited in my vehicle until 9:00 AM.

I was greeted at the door by salesman Ben Drucker, who noted that he had 18 years of experience assisting buyers.  I told Ben the brand and model of the refrigerator, I wished to buy, a 22 cubic foot, side by side.  Ben said that model, was not in their warehouse.  Another buyer had just taken delivery of the same model, and it had taken 3 months to get here.  I did not have three months.  Using bagged ice cubes, in a picnic cooler, for refrigeration would get old, even for me, before three months.

Walla!  They did have one model, of my brand choice, in the warehouse, a giant 28 cubic foot behemoth, that was a totally different style, and cost $500.00 dollars more, than the model I wanted.  It had French Doors, and a lower unit freezer.  That is not great for an old codger like me.  (Think bending over every day to take out frozen meat, etc.)  Ben said they could deliver the monster, on September 13th.  The doors would have to be removed but they could get it into my townhome.  Sept. 13th?  Okay,  I got myself into this jam, by waiting till my old unit bit the dust.  So waiting 11 days for delivery was proper penance, I guessed.  Wrong again.

Ben informed me of the current Labor Day Sale, and detailed two specific rebates, calculated the amounts, and I decided to bite the bullet, spend some money, and avoid having to go through this stressful process each time one of my other five appliances gave up the ghost, as I myself also got older, and older, and probably even less competent.

A tragic choice on my behalf.  Remember that old Truism?  "If it ain't broke, don't fix it."

So, I also chose a new range, microwave, and dishwasher,( I used the old one maybe 5 times in 9 years, just to keep the seals good, as I had read that one wants to do, if one prefers washing his dishes in the kitchen sink.  You do know that hand washed dishes are cleaner.)  I figured if I ever move out of the metro area, to escape the people of the metro area, the new owners will want a dishwasher, and they'll like the fact that all the appliances are the same brand.  And so I added a washer and dryer too. Got out the credit card and paid.  That's how we do it in America.


If the hook up for the water to your new refrigerator is not up to code, you have to get a plumber to install a new three dollar part, or they will not install the fridge.  It's a complicated world.  Warners Stellian has plumbers, and will update your connection for 300 bucks, Ben promised.   I told Ben I would have to check mine. ( Jeez, and maybe clean out space in my unit so the delivery guys can get in the door.  Yes.  I do not clean.  Hey.  I do bathe semi-regularly.  When you get older,  you don't have to bathe every day.  If you do, you will get even drier skin.  Honest. You can look it up.)  

Maybe I could get my brother to install it for me. (turns out he and his wife were on a well deserved vacation.)  So I called Ben Drucker.  It was his day off.  Called again the next day, and ordered the plumber.  It was only $241.00 not $300.00.  Yay!   

I also asked Ben about a third rebate, that I had seen online, on the Warners Stellian Web Site.  Ben had not mentioned this 3rd rebate.  With my six Labor Day Sale appliance purchases, that rebate was for 1000 dollars.   Ben says gee willikers, did I neglect to mention that 1000 dollar rebate?  Yup.  You did Ben.  Ben says yes, I am eligible.  A small alarm goes off in my head.   My confidence and my trust in Ben Drucker goes downhill, a bit.  

Ben says that I will have to pay the $241.00 before delivery.  I said I do not wish to drive all the way to Woodbury, for that.  Ben says he will send me a link, and I can pay online.  I say fine.  It is just a bit after 9 AM.   Ben sends me the link around 3PM that day, six hours later.   So I think to myself, that there is no rush, I'll do it tomorrow.  There is still a week before delivery.  Tomorrow comes, and first I go down to Stillwater, and do some stairs.  I try to do stairs, once every two weeks….in case I have to slay a dragon.  I forgot to turn on my phone ringer.  When I get home from Stillwater, and dragon training,  I note a voice message on my phone.  And I also turn the ringer back on.  The voice message is from Jason Weatherby, the sales manager at Woodbury, Minnesota, who leaves me a polite, professional, ULTIMATUM!  I pay the $241.00 by noon, or they don't deliver my six appliances as scheduled…in a week.   He left the message at 9:47 AM.  So he gave me 2 hours and 13 minutes to pay up.   Really?  They already had about $6,500.00 of my money.   But I must pay the $241.00 before noon today, or they don't deliver in a week?  I am not happy.  I note that it is 20 minutes past the ultimatum deadline.  I call Jason and swear two blue streaks at him.  I inform him that they better deliver as scheduled, in a week.  I give Jason my credit card info, verbally, and pay up.  Done again, with some time to think about it, I would tell Jason Weatherby to stick it, and to refund me all of my money.  That would have saved me a lot of grief. But, of course, the ice was melting in my cooler.  So I swore at him, and then let Jason Weatherby walk on me. (Note: I was back at climbing stairs in Stillwater yesterday, 12 days later.  Bring on the dragon.)  


So I am not told about a 1000 dollar rebate, and then comes ultimatum time over a pittance?  Warners Stellian is very good at getting paid.


The plumber comes the day before delivery.  He is friendly, knowledgeable, and fast.  He has people skills too.  I like the plumber.

The delivery guys come the next day, on the 13th of September.  They work hard, removing refrigerator doors, reinstalling etc.  Four of the six appliances are installed.  The bolts for the Microwave are too short, so that will have to wait. Installation was rescheduled for six days later.   I have them put it on the floor, still in the box, so they do not have to haul it back to the truck, etc.   When they unbox the range outside, they note that the whole side of the range is caved in.  I go out and look.  Yes. I agree with them, that will have to go back.  Of course they have already unhooked the gas line, and removed my old stove, which is now down the stairs and outside.  They will bring my old stove back in and hook it up, if I wish.   They promise that a new range can be delivered in two days.  I decide to be cooperative, and to just do without any range at all for two days.  My old Microwave is still hooked up.   And they have accidentally poked a small, 3/5 of an inch, but deep, hole into the wall near the bottom of the stairs, when removing my old refrigerator.  (later, I see that there is another teeny, tiny hole farther down the wall). They took a picture of the bigger one, and sent it somewhere.  They say that management and I will have to discuss that, and probably someone will have to come out and repair the hole, and repaint the wall.

They worked hard.  I have spackling compound, and a bit of red paint, as I had painted that wall just 4 years ago.  (I had painted my lower level, and the main level, with its 12 ft ceilings.  When I got done, I sold that big heavy ladder.  I was done painting 12 ft high walls.)  So Instead of whining,  I patched and painted it myself.  If you examine the wall carefully, you can find the bigger repair.  I am not a professional.

So I got 4 of my 6 appliances.   The range was delivered and installed two days later, as promised.

Then the microwave was installed another 4 days later.  That is three days of installations.   Three different pairs of installation teams.   After the Microwave crew left,  (They were way early. Mine was their last install of the day, apparently they were independent contractors from California.  They wished to get done and gone fast.) I saw that they had poked two small holes in the wall,above the range, but below the frame of the Microwave, and not said a word about it.  They had not even wiped the wall clean of the installation dust and dirt.  Maybe they thought I would not see the holes in the wall through the dirt?   I was not a happy man, but I decided it was easier to just fix it, and paint it myself….. again.  (Yes.  The kitchen, and thus that wall too, is the same red.  My mom liked bright colors.  I get it from her.   When I move the new owners can repaint.)

So I finally have six new appliances. Are we good to go?  Get serious.


Ben who had neglected to tell me about the 1000 dollar rebate, had told me that I was eligible for all three rebates.   I read the rebate directions.  The directions on one of the rebates said that I could only apply for one rebate.  Since I did not want to apply for a rebate, I was not entitled to get, and possibly ruin my potential for any rebate, I tried to get more information.  No.  I did not call Ben.  He had already broken the trust, as earlier noted.  So I called the main Warners Stellian Office, in St. Paul, and tried to talk to the General Sales Manager.  Good luck with that.  So, I told the secretary, the info that I needed, and she transferred me to another woman, who listened, was friendly, and suggested, that I talk to Ben.  It turns out that she was the manager of the Snelling Ave. store.  How did I get her?  At Warners Stellian they don't want to talk to you, so they transfer your call…wherever.  So word got to Ben, of course, and he called me the next day and explained, finally, that two of the rebates were Warners Stellian rebates, and that the other one, the one that said only one rebate allowed, was a separate manufacturers rebate.   

So I send 5 pages of receipts each, and fill out application forms for three different promised rebates, totaling 12 pages, each.  Yes.  I did print copies of all of those pages, of all three applications. I can prove it. (Which I, of course, have told everyone, that I have asked for help, every time ,I have talked to anyone.  And of course, none of them give a crap.) On all three rebate applications you are asked to indicate whether you want a virtual prepaid card ( duh? what is that?) or a physical card….which takes longer to receive.  On each of the three, I indicate a physical card.  I want to use my cards at the grocery store, so I can pay for food, chocolate, nuts and ice cream.

On October 3rd, I get an email notifying me that my application has been approved and congratulating me on my virtual card, which is here online.  Just click below, where it says Redeem Virtual Card.  WTF?

I call the Nationwide Marketing Group and get "Gustavo" who takes all of my info four times,  I think it was actually five times, in a 12 minute call, but I am saying four, as I wish to be careful not to exaggerate, in which Gustavo's only objective was to stall, stall, stall. He never answered a question or even acknowledged the problem.  I asked to talk to his supervisor.  He ignored my request.  I asked to talk to anyone else.  He ignored me.   I stated that I wanted a physical card, and would not accept a virtual card.  I hung up.

Eight days later October 11, I called the only number I have for Nationwide Marketing Group, again, and got "Martin".  Martin took all of my information, hemmed and hawed etc.  I asked for his supervisor.  He says he does not have one, that they are independent contractors,  and that I should call card services.  I told him I already tried that through the tape recording at Nationwide Marketing Group,  and that the first thing I am required to do is enter the credit card number.  I do not know it.  If I click on the Redeem Virtual Card, to get the number, I will have just accepted their fricking virtual card, that I did not request and do not want.  He finally says I should call Black Hawk, and gives me a phone number.  Who is Black Hawk? I ask.  He says that's the company that Nationwide Marketing Group has hired to handle card services.  I say that I have never seen that name in any Warners Stellian info, nor in any Nationwide info, and am not calling a number I do not know, and then giving them all of my personal info, (because an English, as a second language, contractor, who has no last name, suggests that I call. Yah. Yah. Yah.  Save the lecture.  If you have to speak on the phone, to a human being, in this country, regarding almost all things, phone, internet, cable, online shopping, anything, it will be someone at some remote, far away place, who speaks, supposedly speaks, English as a second language.) Let's move on.

So I call my buddy Ben.  It is Ben's day off, so I leave a detailed message on Jason Weatherby's recorder,  asking for help and for him to call me back.  He does not.  Are you surprised by that?  If so you are the only person who bothered to read this, that is in fact surprised.

Today, I call Ben and he answers the call directly, not the secretary.  It is 9 AM and Ben is going to sell something to that caller.  Nope.  Its me Ben.  Do you remember me?  You sold me six new appliances, that cost me close to 7000 dollars, with installation costs.  Subtract any rebates….hahahaha….. of course.  Yup.  Ben does remember me.  I tell Ben the story of the virtual card, the impossibility of getting it straightened out through Nationwide Marketing Group.  I ask Ben if he has heard of Black Hawk.  He has not.  But says I should call them, as rebates are not Warners Stellian's problem.  I say they work for you, it is your problem and your responsibility.  Ben disagrees.  He says to call Black Hawk.  I say that I will give him the number that I was given by Marvin, and he can call Black Hawk,  confirm that they work for  Nationwidewide Marketing Group, who works for you.  Then send me an email so stating and include the phone number, so that I have a record tying them directly to you, and your employer, Warners Stellian.   Ben says no.  He won't do it.  I promise Ben that I am not walking away from my 1000 dollar rebate.  That I will post to Facebook, call the Attorney Generals Office, State of Minnesota, Consumer Affairs Division,  The Better Business Bureau, and U. S. Senator Amy Klobuchar's Office.   

I have not heard anything at all, as yet, on the second promised Warners Stellian Rebate, also processed by NationwideWide Marketing Group, of course.  Stay tuned.


"Beware Warners Stellian !!!".


Feel free to share this tale, and to warn all of your friends, and everyone you meet on the street, about Warners Stellian.


 


Friday, August 24, 2018

Appalachian Trail 2018 Election Scam

Appalachian Trail 2018 Election Scam
The social service agency known as the Appalachian Trail Conservancy is a political fiefdom which presents a slate of candidates it has chosen to be board members; conducts a sham election in which ATC members may vote either for, or against it’s whole slate of board anointed candidates. It then announces that all chosen candidates have been elected. The most recent scam was August 12, 2018. The ATC does not even announce a tally of yes/no votes. To acknowledge the pittance of members who participate, to recognize any no votes, would be to admit any resistance to this farce. This contrived election is, of course, exactly how all third world repressive, dictatorial regimes conduct business. Exactly.
A very small number of elitist reformers wield total control in this organization. They have the power and now consciously choose to manipulate all things ATC.
This successful, well established organization, has hired professional fundraisers and is reaping a whole lot of donated money. The funding rich ATC has broadened its reach by using the good name of the trail as platform to lobby causes and a political agenda, that have nothing to do with the trail. The hijacked Appalachian Trail is now merely a forum for the politics of the very few who control the donated money.

ATC members may easily verify the truth of these statements by examining the content of the 4 most recent issues of the ATC publication. “A.T. Journey’s” has clearly transitioned both explicitly, and subtly, into the social engineering voice of this lobbying effort, the indoctrinating voice of this political perspective. Every issue in the last year is replete with political indoctrination.
1
Recognize that your donated dollars are being spent for political causes that have nothing whatsoever to do with preserving and protecting the Appalachian Trail.
The ATC through “A. T. Journeys” fosters the politicized, unsupported, meaningless, gobbledygook of the far left. Examples quoted from said issues:
“with a focus on inclusion of those within the opportunity gap”; “promoting diversity and inclusion on public lands”;

“are achieving collective impact”
“by placing a priority on equity and seeking access for underrepresented youth”

The following is a quoted statement decrying a seen excess of old, white, males, by Sandra Mara, Board Chair of the ATC.
“Women and people of color are still in the minority on our trails. Staffs of conservation non profits (The Appalachian Trail Conservancy included) continue to be predominantly white and often predominantly male. Board’s fare even worse, where older, white men still represent the majority of nonprofit leadership.”
How is it that a public relations professional spouts such nonsense? What a travesty, to be burdened by all of these educated, informed, successful, old, white, males, who have volunteered their time, knowledge, experience; and their money? Truly a travesty in need of remediation by these self appointed arbiters of political and social correctness, a dilemma of epic proportions.
I object to being force fed the politics of board member Shalin Desai, who under the guise of a hiking report states “As a queer, South Asian male, I tapped into the LGBT and South Asian
2
directories....” Although I was surprised to be told that the ATC has actually separated AT hikers into ethnic and gender categories, in directories, I don’t care about Mr. Desai’s chosen ethnic, nor gender identity. How does that relate to preserving and protecting the trail? It does not. The whole article was simply an artificially constructed guise to allow said board member and his LGBT friend, whom he interviewed, to shout ‘look at me! I’m LGBT and a board member!’
I don’t give a crap if every board member is LGBTQ, or from Mars.
I expect that the Rainbow Coalition supporters that I have met on the AT, the CT, and in life, will attest to the truth of that statement.

I do object to board members, from top to bottom, using the ATC as a platform for personal politics.
What self anointed, self righteous, group has assigned themselves to recruit members based on ethnicity? Answer; ATC.
What are the ATC established quotas for women and non whites on the trail? What is the quota for whites? For males? What is the quota for each age group? God forbid any age, ethnic, sexual, religious group be “underrepresented”!
What self appointed zealot is out there on the trail identifying the ethnicity, gender, politics, and so on, ad infinitum, of all hikers, and pronouncing judgement on same? Answer: The ATC.
What organization is victim of its own intellectual absurdity? Answer; ATC.
The goal of this misguided national social crusade is to ethnicize and genderize every governmental and social activity, every
3
breath each citizen, and non citizen takes. The agenda of these so called “progressives” is to divide all humans into ethnic, age, and sexual categories, and then to celebrate all things not white male: as if this robotic categorical division, this egalitarian insistence on blind numerical representation of all things human, will somehow benefit American Society, much less the Appalachian Trail.
How did that crusade work out for them in the 2016 presidential election? Not so much. No. I did not vote for Trump. But I do understand why desperate citizens, weary of being derogatorily categorized by ignorant zealots, made that choice.
I love the Appalachian Trail. But I will not support an ultra left elitist clique of political puppets who have hijacked that trail, and the good will of those who love it, to promote their own political agendas.
It is not now, nor has it ever been their trail.
If you happen to be a member of this organization, if you happen to contribute money to it, recognize that you are financing a far left, social elitist, “progressive” lobby.
If you happen to be an American whose politics is anywhere a fraction to the right of antifa extreme left anarchy,

if you happen to be weary of being targeted for racial, and sexual discrimination, and condemnation on the basis of an accident of birth;
If you object to social and political indoctrination, by self anointed morality sensors;

Then you may wish to reconsider your membership, you may wish to find a different venue to support the American hiking trails, which, (to the apparent consternation of the ATC), belong in fact to the people of America, all of the people of America.
4
I thru-hiked the AT in 2013. I have been a member of the ATC, and contributor, since 2011. My objective has been to celebrate and support a National Scenic Hiking Trail.
It was never to be lectured as to what to think, nor indoctrinated as to how to act.

I am done! Not any more! No Mas! Both my membership, and my money will cease in September 2018.
I encourage you also to vote with your money. Join me. Keep it.
Please note that prior to today, I have written in this journal about hiking. Today out of disappointment and absolute frustration; I wrote this note, and I am also posting copies of the two letters, I wrote earlier, and sent to the ATC. Aside from sending my money for seven years, these two letters have been my only other interactions with this organization.
George R. Finn, Jr.
5

Open Letter to Appalachian Trail Conservancy

Letter to the Editor:
Open Letter to the Appalachian Trail Conservancy Date: 5 February, 2018.

The Hijacking of the Appalachian Trail
Has it now become imperative to award a position of board membership to each person who celebrates claim to every identifiable gender, ethnic, racial, social, political, and religious group? To guarantee absolute equity in all things human? Is board membership to be handed out like candy, at a Fourth of July parade, making certain that each child gets his/her allotted piece?
Or is it most important to appoint the individuals to board membership, who have the best proven qualifications, the best ability to achieve the goal of preserving and protecting the Appalachian Trail?
One would guess, that members having demonstrated social, political, and financial, skills and experience; with demonstrated good judgement, would be the strongest forces in achieving that goal. Which again is to preserve and protect the Appalachian Trail.
It’s about the trail!
Is it imperative to appoint board membership to those whose first thought is; “Me, me, me; and my social, my political, my ethnic, agenda? How can I use the Appalachian Trail as a platform to promote my goals?”
Or, as stated in AT Journeys, is it about service? Might it be more beneficial to appoint board membership to those whose first thought is “the trail, the trail, the trail”?
Regarding AT Journeys, January 2018, and board member Mr. Shalin Desai’s celebration of being a “Queer, South Asian male”: I really do not care. If you are a “Queer, South Asian male”, good for you. Tell me all about it as we hike the trail together. If one's major motivation and qualification for being an ATC Board Member is to advocate for those identities, as he clearly has done in said issue, and not the AT itself, then appointing him to represent me, an ATC member, was ill advised.
While I happily agree that his perspectives would provide opportunity for interesting conversation along the trail, interaction that may be productive to both parties; I have no desire to be lectured, to be indoctrinated, to be held hostage to gender, ethnic, social, political, religious, ideologies, as part of ATC membership. Mr. Desai informed us that
1
in seeking advice prior to hiking the AT, that he sought exclusively, the segregated opinions of those who shared his gender, ethnic and social identities. Why did he not simply query input from all former thru-hikers? Is this inclusiveness?
This achievement of board membership, this leeching onto an established organization, and then holding the membership captive to one’s ideologies, to promote one’s causes, is not something to celebrate. This apparent transition of board membership of the ATC and of the publication AT Journeys, into a personal launching platform for political and social agenda, a personal forum of self interest, a personal crusade of advocacy; this use of the ATC name, membership, and money, to promote personal self interest, is ill advised.
The Appalachian Trail is the people’s trail.
The ATC certainly was never intended to be your platform of indoctrination, a venue to lobby your causes. To assert the pretense of impartiality, to decry political polarization, in AT Journeys, and then to participate in it, is dishonest. Campaign for your causes on your own time. Resist reducing the world’s most famous hiking trail to a mere forum for your own personal ideologies.
The Appalachian Trail, and the experience of hiking on it, is a treasure. It is intended to be enjoyed by everyone.
The focus of the ATC and your publication AT Journeys, in representing it, must be the trail and all of the people who tread on it.
George R. Finn, Jr.
Thru-hiked the AT in 2013, and an ATC Member
2

Letter to Appalachian Trail Conservancy

Date: 9 March 2016

Dear Sirs/Madams,
I am an ATC member, who has read with interest the information provided, regarding the proposed $1,268,140.00 High Impact Visitor Use Management Project. I support this plan in general, but have serious concerns regarding the Campsite Restoration and Creation, section of the plan.
I thru-hiked the AT in 2013. Since I did not “Slack Pack”, I spent more evenings camped on the trail than some hikers. Finding a flat surface where I could put up my tent; within the parameters of the federal, state, ATC, and local trail club laws/rules/ guidelines/expectations; was the most difficult/frustrating challenge of my hike. This was especially true in the northern one third of the hike.
There is a serious lack of campsites on many parts of the trail.
There were instances where it was not possible to adhere to the laws/rules/ guidelines/expectations, regarding trail use. The only option was to get off the trail, or to ignore the prescriptions of proper hiker conduct. I do understand clearly that you do not wish to hear that.
It is clear to me also, that the High Impact Visitor Use Management Project fails to address this critical issue. This plan sticks it’s head in the sand, and fails to address the lack of usable camp sites.

You propose to spend one million, two hundred sixty eight thousand, one hundred and forty dollars. Most of that money will be spent on Public Relations, Education, Technology, and ATC expansion.
You propose to spend thirty thousand dollars, a pittance, to actually physically improve campsites. Are you kidding me?

It is apparent, that it is possible to become so committed to, so fixated on, protection and preservation, that one loses awareness that the Appalachian Trail exists to be hiked. This trail serves no purpose, if people are not able to use it.
There are designated areas in this country that do restrict all human trespass in the name of protection and preservation. The AT is not one of them. These areas are not called trails.
The many governing entities at the federal, state, local and mountain club levels, and the ATC itself, may succeed in keeping the trail absolutely pristine, only by restricting
all trespass, by any human being. And then we can all look at pretty pictures of the trail and feel blessed.
Extreme positions, promoting preservation and protection, above all else, are not reasonable, regarding public trails. There needs to be some balance, some compromise, between the unachievable ideal of total preservation/protection; and the necessity to acknowledge and to accommodate the camping needs of visitors who actually use this trail.
This plan fails to address the very significant, very practical, very basic, needs of visitors to this trail. Put real money into making the trail useable by visitors.
This letter is an attempt to remind you, that ultimately the Appalachian Trail was conceived, built, and exists; that people may use it.
Sincerely,
George R. Finn, Jr.

Saturday, August 1, 2015

Done

8/1/2015


Done


The Colorado Trail is done.  Hiked 40 days....took 4 days off....equals 44 days.
It is a beautiful state....a beautiful trail....and the people are beautiful.  Hiking the CT was truly a blast.  It was way more fun than I had dared to anticipate.  "Hawkeye".   




Friends

These are pictures of a few of my new friends.  I do not have pictures of many of you. You know who you are....and so do I.